I found today’s CNN article, “Survey: Americans switching faiths, dropping out” interesting on many levels. The article states, “More than one-quarter of American adults have left the faith of their childhood for another religion or no religion at all, the survey found. Factoring in moves from one stream or denomination of Protestantism to another, the number rises to 44 percent.”
I should state for the record that I’m one of the Americans who has moved “from one stream or denomination to another.” And I see a lot of my friends in the same position; not because we all attend the same church, quite the contrary. One friend of mine began Episcopal and is now involved in the Church of Christ. Another grew up in a baptist church and is now a Lutheran minister.
The article states that our American culture is open to change and this trend of switching faiths makes sense because of it. I’m not sure that changing denominations is actually changing faiths. Faith is from God and as Christians we believe there is “one Lord, one faith, one baptism (Eph 4:5).” Most denominations are distinguished by theological frameworks and their understanding of how God works in us. Non-denominational congregations are more often marked by personality and worship style than by theology. And this is an important distinction.
“In the past, certain religions had a real holding power, where people from one generation to the next would stay,” said Penn State University sociologist Roger Finke, who consulted in the survey planning. “Right now, there is a dropping confidence in organized religion, especially in the traditional religious forms.”
While Finke may be right on some level in this statement about confidence in organized religion, I’m not sure that you can get that from the survey …. at least not with the level of detail that CNN has provided. This is his conjecture about why this shift is happening. I think there may be something more to this trend.
The article states, “On the Protestant side, changes in affiliation are swelling the ranks of nondenominational churches, while Baptist and Methodist traditions are showing net losses. Many Americans have vague denominational ties at best. People who call themselves ‘just a Protestant,’ in fact, account for nearly 10 percent of all Protestants.”
If this is true, and in my “neck of the woods” it seems to be, then theologians have to ask one another why are nondenominational churches “swelling” and denominational churches “showing net losses.” If we let only the sociologists comment we will get only sociological answers. But if we believe that there may be theological implications we must speak out about them.
I believe there are theological implications here. The church has been too quick to substitute good theological education for entertainment-driven messages. When families and persons are not grounded in theological understanding and knowledge, they can be carried away by the sparkling messages that tickle the ears. When entertainment is bringing butts to pews (instead of God), eventually the eyes and ears carried with them are going to get bored and looking for the next shiny thing that catches their attention. Maybe there is a diminishing confidence in traditional religion because too often our religious leaders are: 1) using entertainment to get people in the door; 2) worrying more about the packaging of the message than the truth of the message; 3) crafting messages they think people want to hear.
No one trusts a snake oil salesman!
Church-goers seem to be following personalities more than they are following Christ or the Scriptures. I think Paul has something like this in mind when he writes in 1 Corinthians 1:10-17,
Now I urge you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you all say the same thing, that there be no divisions among you, and that you be united with the same understanding and the same conviction. For it has been reported to me about you, my brothers, by members of Chloe’s household, that there are quarrels among you. What I am saying is this: each of you says, “I’m with Paul,” or “I’m with Apollos,” or “I’m with Cephas,” or “I’m with Christ.” Is Christ divided? Was it Paul who was crucified for you? Or were you baptized in Paul’s name? I thank God that I baptized none of you except Crispus and Gaius, so that no one can say you had been baptized in my name. I did, in fact, baptize the household of Stephanas; beyond that, I don’t know if I baptized anyone else. For Christ did not send me to baptize, but to preach the gospel—not with clever words, so that the cross of Christ will not be emptied [of its effect].
The theological implications, the salvific implications of the move toward personality or entertainment driven ministries is critical to the spiritual health of the American church. We must not let sociologists tell us it is just a matter of a fluid culture when people change faiths. If God is drawing someone to change denominations that is one thing, but if church-goers are chasing the sparkling entertainment driven messages popular among some congregations then there is real risk to spiritual health. In fact, these church-goes may be spritiually dead and not know it.
If congregational leaders are trading the truth of the Gospel for a lie packaged in feel-good wrappers, this is not a crisis of faith or relgious economy but of it is a crisis of spritual truth.
Jesus warns about the dangers in Matthew 7:13-27, when he not only warns us about building our faith on shifting sands but also declares that the path to the Kingdom of God is through the narrow gate. In this passage he also warns us about false teachers, who have signs and miracles but do not obey the Word of God.
The researcher says, “The American religious economy is like a marketplace — very dynamic, very competitive,” said Luis Lugo, director of the Pew Forum. “Everyone is losing, everyone is gaining. There are net winners and losers, but no one can stand still. Those groups that are losing significant numbers have to recoup them to stay vibrant.”
Just because the fruit is polished and looks good on the outside, it doesn’t mean that the substance of the fruit is good. American media wants us to believe that we don’t have to obey the Bible, that its more important not to offend any one than it is to be obedient to God. The Bible says something different, “For am I now trying to win the favor of people, or God? Or am I striving to please people? If I were still trying to please people, I would not be a slave of Christ. (Gal 1:10)”
We must not trade the truth for sparkling messages that seem vibrant on the outside. True vibrance is in the life-giving Gospel of the Jesus.